28 kHz vs 40 kHz at 60 W: what actually changes?
The same stated power does not make two cleaning systems equivalent. Compare the frequency, assembled transducer, generator and loaded tank together; the values in this question are not an approved Sunnytec rating.
Three checks
Read the power statement before comparing performance
The power in the buyer’s question is a proposed comparison, not a certified rating for a specific Sunnytec item. Check what each supplier means by that figure and which operating conditions accompany it. Identical labels can conceal different generator arrangements, mounting conditions and duty requirements. Lower-frequency cavitation is generally more vigorous, while audible noise also depends on the tank, fixtures and loading. A louder installation is not evidence of a better process. Compare cleanliness, surface condition and equipment behaviour under a documented test rather than ranking samples by the sound they make.
Treat oil removal as a process question
For robust parts with heavy contamination, a lower-frequency option may deserve evaluation. Start by checking whether the cleaning liquid can wet and remove the actual oil or residue. Examine bath condition, preparation and part placement before attributing a failed trial to frequency. If an oil film is merely redistributed, the process has not achieved its purpose. Increasing drive power is not an appropriate substitute for correcting exhausted or incompatible chemistry. Ask the process owner to define an inspectable end point and use that same end point for every candidate. Approved operating values remain subject to the approved specification.
Check the assembled resonator, not ceramic thickness alone
Ceramic thickness can affect a vibration mode, but it does not by itself define the operating behaviour of an assembled cleaning transducer. The ceramic material, metal components, joints, preload and mounting boundary form a mechanical system. A replacement that looks similar may still have a different response when fitted. Request an impedance trace and the relevant installation drawing for the assembled condition. Have the generator supplier review compatibility as well. Neither a thickness measurement nor a matching label is sufficient evidence that the replacement can be installed without further engineering work.
Where this does not apply
This discussion does not prescribe a frequency for every oil-contaminated part. Thin walls, coatings and previously qualified processes may impose different restrictions. Power labels from different equipment suppliers may also use different measurement conventions. If the machine documentation restricts the operating frequency or replacement assembly, obtain an approved change before proceeding. A cleaning test cannot establish electrical interchangeability when the drive interface has not been checked.
How to verify
Start with the existing component identification, mounting drawing, generator information and a record of the accepted cleaning recipe. Submit these for compatibility review before an energized trial. Once the setup is approved, test representative contaminated parts and record residue, surface changes and operating observations consistently. Preserve the installed configuration and loading details with the results. A satisfactory unloaded sample is not a substitute for a loaded-tank trial, and a successful trial applies only to the documented combination until a wider operating envelope has been agreed. Ask the reviewer to record why the chosen candidate passed and why the alternative did not. That decision record is more useful for a later replacement than a purchase order containing only the nominal frequency and power.
Shantou Sunnytec Electronics Co., Ltd.EN